When Aurora Casket Co. opened a health clinic at its
factory in the small town of Aurora, Indiana, in December
2009, Nyetta Niklas never expected it would mean so much to
her and her family.
But the accounting assistant
is convinced the clinic helped save her husbandfs life last
year by diagnosing a possible ministroke and then streamlining
his admission to a nearby hospital after he fell ill again.
gIt probably helped him from having a major stroke,h Niklas
says.
While employee health clinics
are typically established to provide occupational health or
primary-care services for organizations grappling with soaring
medical costs, the clinics have helped save lives—by
diagnosing cancer, heart disease and other conditions early
on—while holding down medical costs.
gWe want a happier, healthier
workforce,h says Camille Healy, director of employee benefits
and general counsel, at Aurora Casket. After a little more
than a year, the clinic boasts a utilization rate of 60 to 70
percent, Healy says. Many visits are from employees who
havenft been to a doctor in years. With the clinic, she
estimates, emergency room visits because of illness have
dropped by 50 percent. On the financial side, gour goal is to
break even. If we save money, great.h
On-site
clinics arenft brand new. Indeed, SAS Institute Inc., a
software company in Cary, North Carolina, established a clinic
27 years ago. In the past couple of years, SAS has received an
upsurge of calls from other employers interested in setting up
on-site clinics. When organizations are debating whether to
establish a clinic, a key question is: gHow important are your
employees to your bottom line?h says Gale Adcock, director of
corporate health services at SAS. gItfs not just saving money
today; itfs saving money tomorrow.h Getting an employeefs
diabetes and hypertension under control now, she adds, may
help stave off a heart attack down the road.
A 2009 survey by the
consultancy Mercer found that 34 percent of employers with
more than 500 workers offer on-site or near-site clinics. Most
focus on occupational health services, while 13 percent offer
primary-care services. gHealth care reform has catalyzed many
employers to pursue on-site clinics,h says Bruce Hochstadt,
head of Mercerfs on-site clinic consulting group. Under the
new health reform legislation, 30 million to 40 million more
people will be covered for medical care. gItfs likely to
strain an already stretched delivery system,h he
says.
With health care costs
increasing 10 to 15 percent annually and more claims
translating into higher insurance premiums, the city of
Clearwater, Florida, opened its own clinic July 1 to try to
curb costs. Following a model used by many organizations, the
city contracted with a third party, which is responsible for
operating the clinic. Clearwater pays Care ATC of Tulsa,
Oklahoma, a monthly administrative fee and covers all of the
actual clinic costs, such as staff salaries, medications,
equipment and office supplies.
Because the clinic opened at
midyear, the city budgeted $750,000 for its operation in 2010.
This year, its budget is $1.5 million. While itfs too early to
see the return on investment, Clearwater eventually expects a
return of 2 or 3 to 1. That means spending $1 million would
ultimately save the city $2 million to $3 million. Such
savings come from using the on-site clinics, rather than more
expensive outside providers; treating problems early on before
they become more severe; and reducing lost work time for
medical appointments outside the workplace.
With doctor visits and
medications free for the cityfs 1,700 employees and their
dependents who are on the cityfs health plan, officials hope
employees will be motivated to seek regular care. gHopefully
we prevent that catastrophic claim later,h says Joseph Roseto,
human resources director for Clearwater.
On-site health clinics may
reach employees who typically avoid seeking health care.
gThere are people who use the clinics that never would have
used services out in the community,h says Patricia
Berger-Friedman, a senior consultant with Towers Watson &
Co. Because on-site doctors typically devote 15 or 30 minutes
to each patient, the physician can have ga conversation more
around the health of the individual,h rather than just
focusing on the problem the employee is experiencing at the
moment, Berger-Friedman says. For example, a chronic sore
throat could be tied to smoking, and the companyfs doctor
might recommend a smoking cessation program offered in the
workplace.
Itfs also easier to monitor
chronic conditions. Pat Sweet, medical clinics manager at
Pitney Bowes Inc., a Stamford, Connecticut, mail and document
services company, was able to keep one diabetic employee off
medication for almost two years by providing advice and
monitoring her condition every two weeks.
While many workplaces focus on
primary care, Pitney Bowes has expanded its offerings over the
years to include such services as skin cancer treatment;
dental and vision screenings; mammograms; chair massages; and
even immunizations for employees traveling abroad. But this is
the exception to the rule. Most clinics offer primary care or
focus on occupational health issues, and many donft employ
specialists.
Some clinic services are
tailored for a particular employee population. Medcor Inc. in
McHenry, Illinois, operates clinics for a variety of clients
in locations ranging from office buildings to tourist
attractions to construction sites. One of Medcorfs clients is
Clark Construction Group, which is building a seven-story
medical center in Las Vegas for the Department of Veterans
Affairs. The clinic opened in March 2009, treating injuries
incurred on the job or at home, says Matt Moody, Clarkfs
safety manager for the project. If an accident occurs, both
Moody and clinic staff respond, and in serious cases, a Medcor
employee accompanies the patient to the hospital. gIt shows
the patient that you actually care,h he says.
While some clinics, like Clark
Constructionfs, offer a typical facility, SAS, the software
company, operates a top-of-the-line, 35,000-square-foot
center, staffed by 56 employees and equipped with a
full-service, on-site laboratory, as well as nutrition and
tobacco cessation counseling and other services.
Last year it handled more than
37,000 patient visits. Adcock, the health services director at
SAS, says the companyfs return on investment reached $7
million last year when it compared the cost of services
rendered by its clinic with the expense of an outside
provider. The company also factored in the savings from less
work time lost for off-site doctor visits.
SAS program manager Charlie
Morlock says he initially appreciated the convenience of the
clinic for himself and his family. Now hefs grateful for the
quality of care. Four years ago his son, Charlie Jr.,
complained that his foot was sore. Morlock saw a bruise,
thought the then-5-year-old had broken a bone in his foot, and
took the youngster to the SAS clinic. Doctors immediately knew
something was seriously wrong, conducted a blood test and
within 45 minutes determined the boy had leukemia.
Two hours later Charlie Jr.
was at a hospital starting treatment for the disease.
Treatment ended last year, but he still gets his blood tested
each month at SAS. Morlock says if he was offered a job
elsewhere, the SAS clinic would gfactor very heavilyh in
deciding whether he would leave the company.
Workforce Management,
March 2011, p. 6-7 -- Subscribe
Now!
Susan Ladika is a freelance writer in Tampa, Florida. To
comment, e-mail editors@workforce.com.